后浪vs前浪：罗技G913 TKL&樱桃MX10.0超薄无线机械键盘横评
“两千预算旗舰机械键盘怎么选？”今天的评测就是针对这个level的老板来做的，客观直接优缺点全列出，如果对老板们有用就给个三连！1
作为机械开关的创始者，Cherry樱桃无疑是机械键盘的前浪，制定业界标准，多年来既产轴体、又产键盘，还卖专利，过的极度舒适的樱桃虽然生产了不少经典机械键盘，但还是被玩家们冠以固执守旧、创新不足、跟不上潮流等标签，不过随着近年来国内轴体的兴起和各大电竞品牌全面推广机械键盘，樱桃终于感受到了压力，创新推出了mx6.0、8.0、9.0等优秀前卫的产品，今年更是紧跟潮流推出了自家首款矮轴超薄机械键盘MX 10.0。
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x511_jfs/t1/113599/13/10980/87474/5ef60dcaE61c2f0c2/f8c861fbae1636b2.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x575_jfs/t1/121029/19/6657/623532/5f05e321Ed92b0f87/b455e2c5a6ad8cf0.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x510_jfs/t1/118835/25/12020/59495/5f05e326E2c4c941c/5d48344032275a46.jpg
而在2013年才推出首款机械键盘的“后浪“罗技G系列，却在超薄和无线领域创新成为行业的前浪，先于Cherry在2019年推出首款矮轴超薄无线机械键盘G913，又在今年推出升级版G913 TKL，后浪来势凶猛！https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x510_jfs/t1/126421/15/6714/38484/5f05e453E46d70efc/df4981b9ea4f3669.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/65569/8/9423/232021/5d733974E9982bf8f/76a9a1cb64d71e71.jpg
两款旗舰机械键盘都是22毫米厚度超薄设计，裸轴方案，具有RGB灯效，金属面板等。但也有着明显的定位和独特之处。所以下面主要围绕产品做工、轴体、实际使用、可玩性和性价比等方面的对比展开。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/149627/11/2448/224558/5f05e24cE9b7d63b6/041c9692458128c1.jpg
一、浪打浪之——外观做工G913 TKL外包装普通，按照传统把劲儿都用在产品本身：金属原色的阳极氧化拉丝铝面板上部全包裹，纹路清晰质感强烈有科技感，而背面为了耐用、便携和减重采用了工程塑料，面子上非常过得去，毕竟见到的都是好看的！按键分布合理，紧凑精致，尤其是额头处的logo及柔软的橡胶多媒体键、无极音量滚轮是最大亮点。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/128050/35/6667/217620/5f05e198Ee56338fb/86fd8e4018465633.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/130423/32/4014/255561/5f05e19cE3ffeb350/93559c5bfadbbe00.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/141373/21/2521/261308/5f05e1a0Eec496e1e/d3494bd6adc6a440.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/136201/6/4043/205800/5f05e1baEad010eef/a421c5185dab3183.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/137289/11/3985/257451/5f05e1a5E7756f43d/f100187366f644d7.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/130429/18/4041/241995/5f05e1a9E2356e16c/77e1df8941690333.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/141334/6/2428/256037/5f05e1aeE1617e793/186d7ac6b351ec87.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/129838/22/4072/236414/5f05e1b2Eb7022a6c/95b99bde320a0f59.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/144301/36/2465/243644/5f05e1b6E5bc15c76/b7585b41872427e0.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/121578/1/6688/191487/5f05e1beE96cd5767/9b46e17a92ae4f73.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/118027/37/11740/259709/5f05e1d3E8dff8b3f/f47917fb82bd4075.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/120829/3/6686/195615/5f05e1dcE4eecb880/674f29f2bd09a22c.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/142448/1/2479/236706/5f05e1e5E09209687/6a1e93252353ee8e.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/112350/35/11997/217509/5f05e1e9E19461cd7/c2cb4fccc99ad134.jpg
MX 10 自带军火箱，虽然用处不大还占一定费用，但真的挺酷。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/119350/12/11972/215003/5f05e1faE44447f93/b6b1626eb6974a46.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/124876/24/6601/206838/5f05e203E48645bb4/e498038fc6b14fa0.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/140695/27/2463/183846/5f05e208E1e08fdc0/ecd13de74c08bf84.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/148804/32/2465/297540/5f05e1feE481ae7b2/fbc40d44da857ca5.jpg
黑化磨砂质感的阳极氧化全铝面板，采用超窄边框，104键紧凑型设计，比一般的全尺寸键盘要短很多，整块面板没有一丝多余位置，略拥挤。
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/146848/2/2417/253062/5f05e236E4cf8025c/39f51a61ca71eff6.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/112727/39/12153/177699/5f05e218E9eb4bc5b/f57769a7cc2202d2.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/127324/3/6581/180845/5f05e224E4762caa6/9e8b973f443692ac.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/131346/3/3905/172838/5f05e220E463dd40f/99155e62d98a923e.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/149487/29/2425/275867/5f05e22cE35dff40e/4bed929a138ed8f5.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/114664/11/11877/264875/5f05e228E355f76f5/30615fa647d34c87.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/118231/12/12183/334881/5f05e250E44138e64/a318722ae05693ee.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/128532/23/6670/398631/5f05e25bE88507b39/b709738c53081bc7.jpg
个人感觉最美的地方是阻尼设计的贯穿式撑脚，不但有艺术感也能提供无限多的键盘倾角。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/147393/32/2472/200694/5f05e20cE5db9bb27/97db51275ac55578.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/125182/14/6700/186512/5f05e210E124f7d7a/af795210d05be894.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/119914/12/6643/222830/5f05e214E36302f62/84db4a06543a907a.jpg
此处双方算各有亮点，整体格局方面G913 TKL既紧凑又留有足够空间，这在后续要说的实际使用上占了更大优势！
二、浪打浪之——轴体罗技与凯华合作的GL轴50cN 触发力度，总键程2.7mm，触发键程1.5mm，7000万次寿命。可选茶轴、红轴、青轴。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s748x559_jfs/t1/137037/2/3951/57918/5f05e295E22812ea7/ce80b78e1eda0c1e.jpg
樱桃LP矮红轴45cN 触发力度，总键程3.2mm，触发键程1.2mm，5000 万次寿命。目前仅有红轴可选。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x511_jfs/t1/119405/12/10416/136271/5f05e292Edd4fe3ca/2b955c68b5b17f9a.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x750_jfs/t1/142281/35/2439/21285/5f05e28bE220c9cc5/d6c4689fbb3322ac.jpg
对于用惯传统轴的人，两款都稍偏肉一些。但相比与静音轴，两款又都很有手感。客观来说，GL矮轴相对偏软点（只能说一点），整体较为安静些（只能说一些），索性罗技有三种轴，喜欢清脆体验的还可以选C轴，但触发速度相对更快；而樱桃矮轴回弹力度大一点。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/113755/29/11909/211050/5f05e1c6E966a2df5/f1ca5fe2f9584f8b.jpg
轴体对比差异不大，但罗技选择更多，希望樱桃呢能快速发力抢夺市场。
三、浪打浪之——实际使用手感方面，得益于纤薄的机身，不用手托搭到两款键盘上都很自然舒适，码字行云流水，913tkl采用ABS键帽，相对于MX10 ABS+类肤涂层来说更不容易打油，不过都会容易留下汗渍。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/137520/33/3926/236729/5f05e25fEf5c0ee10/599239a1c2446686.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/138019/13/2383/228732/5f05e263E89d08ea0/e84794c2e85b11c2.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/137234/22/4023/326355/5f05e1e1E6fc3251f/8732962b91e8d33d.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/113530/26/11928/267651/5f05e1f1E88325ce2/ac0660dbd051b9b6.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/136340/2/3940/260904/5f05e231Ee381e6b0/8b0e9565360c8b84.jpg
G913 TKL在吸取了广大用户的意见（狂喷）后，果断去掉了容易误触的G键做成80%序列，尺寸、功能键等都恰到好处。键帽相对MX10较小、间距合适减少误触，但触底稍有晃动，且凯华的猪鼻子轴体插口在清理键帽插拔时要注意一定要直上直下。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/148651/11/2439/414615/5f05e268Eafcfd6cc/1a079f0ae39550e9.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/116864/24/12125/230033/5f05e1c2E205312cd/58804e0830e7bf02.jpg
MX 10采用的无边框设计，键帽面积比正常稍大，加之F区和编辑区离主键又很近，导致刚上手误触率稍高。轴体插口是传统十字，插拔更方便一些。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/130116/34/4044/317520/5f05e1f5Ed0f48bb5/ebec5730dc5b5e24.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/114382/10/11802/231143/5f05e194Ed9f847e8/f413e20a7a4d994d.jpg
四、浪打浪之——可玩性矮轴作为新物种，可替换的键帽等DIY配套几乎没有。之前也有大手子拆解过，G913 TKL使用的灯光组件非常优质，即使在无键帽阻挡的情况下灯光也十分柔和不闪烁，同时还配有Ghub生态驱动，可以设置超多玩法的联动灯效、宏按键等等，当然呢还可以分享使用社区其他玩家的设置，可玩性非常强。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/112106/24/11866/267549/5f05e1d8Eb9076d13/a9244207b8febf69.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/131259/12/3984/224343/5f05e1caE10aa1d64/fc1019f7bd4b6aeb.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/122966/11/6532/246912/5f05e248E14149f1a/995443f358d0bafc.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x543_jfs/t1/134766/40/3938/55515/5f05e6b0E9a915d4f/f4ea9265f394b531.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x543_jfs/t1/147334/31/2428/53649/5f05e6b2Eda95a851/ff3c56918a406c0d.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x543_jfs/t1/130870/26/3985/66768/5f05e6b4E3a60855a/dd775a5d6e5ee446.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x543_jfs/t1/117730/4/11851/54137/5f05e6b7E4b5bb307/65b00ebd5633f5b4.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x543_jfs/t1/118758/26/11795/53873/5f05e6baE37d2d8d7/440de9689c99cccc.jpg
MX 10驱动简洁，灯效中规中矩亮度一般，宏命令较为简陋甚至无循环方式设定。不过驱动内支持在线定制键盘和租用键盘算是比较有趣的玩法。键帽通用大部分mx键帽，但大键位底座较特殊，卫星轴与主轴不在同一直线所以通用性降低。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/140787/19/2424/409817/5f05e256Ec240d32d/aebdddf42b012582.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/147128/35/2426/348978/5f05e244E3616eec1/8bec234fc00aee31.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/134476/34/4046/269496/5f05e23aEe123a81d/77d9e060545b1fd3.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x480_jfs/t1/145410/8/2399/85991/5f05e287Ec66b4c79/a8f0bf765441f468.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x480_jfs/t1/148953/15/2481/67695/5f05e27bEf64b4e49/d5933f2d05b3e9ff.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x444_jfs/t1/115094/4/11911/81762/5f05e27fE37c437fb/a3b2643cc441f268.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x449_jfs/t1/146789/5/2429/86217/5f05e283Ed3215893/edf4c3dae995456c.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/147031/10/2435/204236/5f05e190E86df5bec/14663c77f408fb9e.jpg
在实际选用上，相比于MX 10.0的形单影只，G913系列有全键款和TKL 80%布局款，再加上G813有线版（除了无线几乎没差别），各自又有三种轴可选，所以共有9种选择方案，一家人最重要就是整整齐齐。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x768_jfs/t1/145162/8/2500/32178/5f05e28eE2fa267c1/925d919a6e3ba615.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/131194/18/4096/280871/5f05e18cE961d14a1/927aa21853822939.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/134162/33/4081/250716/5f05e188Ec70b0d43/3c4ff61eab102d72.jpg
五、浪打浪之——性价比罗技从G913上市就1699日常，大促1599，TKL出来延续价格定位。然而它不仅超薄，还有LIGHTSPEED无线、蓝牙双模连接，罗技的无线技术是比较成熟的电竞级解决方案，灯效全开还有40小时续航时间，蓝牙能连pad和手机或者另外一台电脑，等于一拖二可用，所以对于价格很是硬气。Cherry mx10在67周年发布，售价999元，然而快速拉升至日常1599，促销1499，这是什么样的心路历程“小老弟也敢卖1699，老大哥还能比你差？？？”https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/124814/40/6704/299291/5f05e1ceEe311ae6b/ce382bbd93b1850b.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/148255/23/2506/212373/5f05e450Ef271630a/c511eca7274757ce.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/134423/14/3980/422646/5f05e272E4b6807a7/2252344da9744643.jpg
六、说在最后矮轴解决了传统轴存在的一些问题，超薄机身无需配置手托（占地方、二次消费），可以做到更薄更便携，以及很关键的触发速度上大幅超越传统轴，同时解决了声音过大问题，让它兼顾了多场景——电竞体验丝毫不差、办公体验爽到爆炸，会逐渐吸引更多传统轴用户，毕竟不是所有人都习惯用在不同场景使用不同键盘，统一的手感会带来高效和愉快，老是换键盘人会精分啊！但是目前来看，矮轴和传统轴的关系，是一种更好的方案，却不会是完全替代的关系，毕竟传统轴已有十多年的受众，在手感和使用习惯上一时不可能轻易改变。https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/134749/37/3998/214518/5f05e185E2ec7e6ef/62650c14e60c1339.jpg
作为科技产品发烧友，对于老品牌的满怀希望，和对于新技术的无力抵抗，常常让人非常矛盾。这一波前浪后浪…浪打浪对比，除了给大家做个参考，也呼吁更多的厂家都能坚持创新，才能让信仰之树常青！https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/123686/16/6574/407285/5f05e26dE2b56b14e/655c2230c915640f.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s768x478_jfs/t1/119691/35/10478/551433/5f05e278E2b4337e4/1c1ee89e7eeeb389.jpg
https://img10.360buyimg.com/promotepic/s750x500_jfs/t1/143185/29/2426/297363/5f05e23eE21971aa3/e45293891a52bd5f.jpg
矮轴键帽一定要做好。不然手感不行，没错我说的是酷冷 2000直接客制化走起 G913 颜值更胜一筹 仰望高端玩家 Cherry不出青轴手感矮轴，干不过罗技
页:
[1]